i'm reading right now, but yea i agree, i think these should be decided and then discussed with cef, some might have been old art from m3o or something, looking through and will post any i disagree with on your rating lolz :P
shiny arcanine is pretty good to me.
shiny beedrill's not to bad.
i like the shiny fearow.
the shiny raichu was really good to me.
nidarino F lines not to bad to me ( not counting megas )
the espeon is really cute, though its body looks a bit to long
shiny dragonair is pretty good
don't really like pikachu
eh shiny growleths not that great
mewtwo and his new mega i don't care for
poocheyena is bad
shiny teentacrool and mega ampharos are creepy
eevee and shiny eevee should go back to old art work